The story of a man who hired the biggest injury law firm in America
I grew up in Portsmouth, and I’ve practiced law in southern Ohio most of my career. Here’s something I’ve known since I was a kid: folks around here don’t ask for much. They want somebody to pick up the phone, tell them the plain truth, not talk down to them, and do what they say they’re going to do. That’s why a story I read this summer has stuck with me.
A 73-year-old craftsman from outside Atlanta was seriously hurt in a car accident. He hired Morgan & Morgan, the largest personal injury firm in the country, whose ads he had seen everywhere. Their slogan promised to be “For the People.” He figured a firm that big would have the muscle to get him a fair deal.
By his account, he spoke with one attorney, one time. Then he dealt with a paralegal. In 2024, his case was settled for $45,000, and he says nobody ever asked him if that was okay.
He took it to arbitration. This July, the arbitrator sided with him on legal malpractice, breach of contract, and breach of fiduciary duty, and awarded him $4.3 million.
In fairness, Morgan & Morgan disagree about the facts in the case. They say the attorney got verbal consent but didn’t put it in writing, and they don’t believe the ruling reflects the facts. I wasn’t there, and I can’t tell you what happened between that man and his lawyers. But I can tell you what the arbitrator decided, and I can tell you why I think it’s worth asking whether any client can get lost when a firm takes on that many cases.
Every one of us has felt the frustration, if not outright rage, of trying to settle a problem with a nameless, faceless voice in a call center. It might be the utility company, the cell phone company, the insurance company, or the online store that left your package at the wrong address. It’s darn near impossible to get anybody to pick up the phone, let alone treat you fairly. The same thing can happen with a big law firm.
You can become a case number, and the person handling your file may be somebody you’ve never met, often not even a lawyer. Cases get settled fast because clearing them means moving on to the next file in the pile. They minimize time on the case to maximize profit. I’m not saying every lawyer at a big firm is careless. I’m saying their income model makes it hard to take the time to dig into the details that can change the outcome.
And here’s the part that matters: the decision to settle is yours, not your lawyer’s. It’s your case, your injuries, and your wellbeing. Nobody can tell you what’s best for you. My job is to tell you what I honestly think it’s worth, lay out your options, and then do what you decide. If you ever walk out of my office not knowing where your case stands, I’ve failed you.
Why that Matters
We drive the same roads you do.
Southern Ohio isn’t Columbus. If you drive in Pike, Ross, Scioto, Jackson, or Hocking County, you know our roads are different from city roads. We’ve got winding two-lane highways with no shoulder, dangerous intersections, and drivers moving at higher speeds, and that can mean more serious crashes and injuries. I’ve been driving these roads my whole life, and I know which curves and intersections have a history of wrecks. After working hundreds of crash cases here, I know which stretches have caused trouble before. That kind of detail can matter, and a lawyer from out of town may not know it.
Getting the facts while they’re fresh
In my experience, getting the facts early can dramatically affect how an injury case turns out. That goes for car, truck, and motorcycle crashes, workplace injuries, dog bites, and wrongful death. Visiting the scene, talking to witnesses, and gathering medical records while details are fresh can make a real difference. Evidence disappears and memories fade.
As my mom always said, “The best day to plant a tree was thirty years ago, and the second-best day is today.” If you haven’t called an injury lawyer yet, don’t think all is lost. But don’t wait. Ohio law gives you only a limited time to file most injury claims, generally two years, so the earlier we start on your case the better.
Knowing how things get done around here
I grew up in Portsmouth and came back after college, law school, and cutting my teeth as a lawyer in other parts of Ohio. When anybody asks me how I like living here, I tell them, “There’s no other place I’d live.”
Living here has been a real advantage in my practice. I know the people who work in our courts, hospitals, and body shops, the EMTs, and the doctors and chiropractors who treat our neighbors. None of that buys anybody special treatment, and I’d never say it does. But I know who to call, how our local courts operate, and where to look for information that can matter in your case. A lawyer who doesn’t live here may not even make the drive to meet you or see where you were hurt. Too often, they rely on police reports and witness statements alone. If they don’t take the time to learn the details of your case, how can they fight for everything it’s worth?
We’ll Do the Lifting So You Can Heal
When you’re hurt, the last thing you need is a pile of paperwork. We can help with medical bills, medical tests, rental cars, child care, and replacement income, so you can focus on getting better.
Our Track Record
Online reviews of big firms rarely tell you anything about the lawyer who’ll actually handle your case. Warren Law Firm is a small firm, and I know every client who walks through our door. We’ve recovered tens of millions of dollars for our clients. While past results don’t guarantee future outcomes, our track record reflects the experience and dedication we bring to every case.
You’re a Neighbor- Not a Number
To us, you’re not a file. You’re a neighbor we may run into at the grocery store or the high school football game or maybe at a local pub. We will fight tooth and nail for our neighbors inside or outside of the courtroom.
We will relentlessly fight on your behalf. You’ll meet face to face, at our office, in the hospital or at your kitchen table if that’s easier. You won’t have to chase us down. You’ll hear from us about any progress with your case or anytime there are any updates about your case including offers, deadlines, and updates about your case.
No settlement will happen without your approval, and I’ll explain it plainly before you decide. I’ll tell you the truth, even when it’s not what you were hoping to hear. I can’t promise any particular result, and no honest lawyer can. What I can promise is that you’ll always know what’s going on with your case, and you’ll always be the one making the call.
If you’ve been hurt anywhere around southern Ohio, give us a call or fill out our case evaluation form to find out if you have a case. The initial consultation is free. We charge you nothing unless we win your case!
Aaron McHenry is the lead attorney at Warren Law Firm. Take a tour of his house below!
Sources: WSB-TV, Hoodline, Larry Forman Law
Attorney Mike Warren, Of Counsel, has been practicing law for more than 30 years.
Attorney Aaron McHenry grew up in Portsmouth and moved to Chillicothe in 2004. Aaron has been practicing law for more than 25 years.
“Trust the lawyers who drive the same roads you do.”
Office Address
174 W. Main St.
Chillicothe, Ohio 45601
Phone: 740-660-2745
Email: info@buckeyelegal.com
Warren Law Firm is a registered trademark of Aaron M. McHenry, Attorney at Law, LLC
Copyright Warren Law Firm | Privacy Policy & Accessibility | Sitemap